Fraters Libertas

Bad Santa

A movie review from Man From Silver Mountain:

There has been some degree of controversy surrounding the Dimension Films release of “Bad Santa.” Many have found it inexcusable that a film would show Santa Claus using foul language, drinking and engaging in disturbing sexual acts. I respect the claim that it is not acceptable to advertise these actions in places where children are likely present. This is an adult film with plot characteristics that may interest children. Therefore, I am disappointed to see it advertised during the Cowboys/Dolphin game on Thanksgiving afternoon. I would prefer to see it advertised after 9 pm.

If you have seen the trailers, you would probably know if you would be offended by it. If so, then may I suggest going to “Elf” instead? It is opposite in tone, sweet and delightful. It is also an excellent movie. As someone who does not care much for Will Ferrell, I must grudgingly admit this is a charming family movie.

Like Ferrell, Billy Bob Thornton is the focal point of his film, but receives help of a talented cast. Lauren Graham is charming as the love interest. Tony Cox provides much of the comedy as Thornton’s partner. Bernie Mac and John Ritter are welcome supporting players. Thornton himself is amazing. He has a history of playing flawed, unlovable characters in movies such as “Sling Blade,” “A Simple Plan,” and “Monster’s Ball.” This is another such performance.

Thornton plays Willie, a safe cracking drunk who uses his seasonal job as Santa Claus to gain access to a different department stores bulging vault each Christmas eve. To call Willie a drunk is an understatement. He is drunk or drinking in every scene of the movie. He is a spiteful, self-loathing wretch with no redeeming characteristics. His level of self-pity is like none I’ve ever seen. Oh, wait. I just saw David Allan Coe last week, so scratch that.

Stories of a horrid man changed at Christmas time are common. Ebenezer Scrooge and the Grinch are classic examples. Art Carney played a drunk who became Santa Claus in an old Twilight Zone episode. Willie is a far more horrid character than any of these. His transformation is rather minor compared to the above characters. However, he had further to go.

The idea that Willie could find and keep work, not to mention an attractive companion like Graham is completely implausible. The movie requires some suspension of disbelief. The movie also could not have any darker humor. It’s style and tone was similar to “Shakes the Clown,” a 1992 comedy about an alcoholic children’s clown. If you liked Shakes, you would love this. I recommend it highly with this caveat: it is an adult movie. Keep the children and anyone who doesn’t appreciate crude or dark humor away.